Tips & Tricks for Building a Customer Loyalty Program

Think of the brands you love. Chances are you have a few favorites you go out of your way to support—whether it’s a clothing line, a distillery, or an automaker. Brand loyalty is a major part of marketing psychology and consumer behavior, and it’s something small businesses should leverage.

Loyalty programs are a fantastic way to tap into the enthusiasm of your best customers. When designed properly, a customer loyalty program allows you to reward your most loyal patrons, offer them exclusive deals, and generate recurring revenue. However, there are some common pitfalls to avoid when preparing your program.

Do Offer Something of Value

One of the biggest mistakes businesses make is launching a customer loyalty program without offering real value. Maybe you’re concerned about giving away too much and end up being overly conservative with your rewards. It’s a delicate balance, and you should carefully review what you can and can’t offer.

However, keep in mind that giving away something trivial or offering a minor 5% discount from time to time likely won’t make your best customers feel appreciated. Put yourself in their shoes and ensure that your rewards, sales, or offers are truly valuable and meaningful.

Do Offer Tiers

Not all loyal customers are the same. Segmenting your loyalty program into tiers allows you to offer different rewards based on engagement levels.

For example, if you’re a restaurant offering a punch card system, consider making the rewards different at each tier. Some customers will be occasional visitors, while others will be true brand advocates. Make sure your top-tier patrons are incentivized with standout rewards that match their loyalty and encourage repeat visits.

Do Tweak Regularly

Consumer preferences change over time—and that’s perfectly normal. That’s why it’s crucial to review and tweak your loyalty program regularly. You can even solicit feedback from a subset of your top customers and incorporate their suggestions.

No matter how you approach it, be sure to adjust your loyalty program over time to stay aligned with your customers’ evolving tastes and expectations.

Don’t Assume Clients Will Automatically Sign Up

A customer loyalty program is a powerful tool for driving revenue and retention—but simply setting it up isn’t enough. You need to actively promote it.

Surprisingly, many businesses create loyalty programs and then neglect to market them, allowing the programs to fade away. When investing in marketing efforts, it’s tempting to focus solely on attracting new customers. But neglecting your existing customer base—and the retention tactics that support them—is a major missed opportunity.

Promote your loyalty program across multiple channels: your website, post-purchase emails, social media posts, and even in-person interactions. Treat your loyalty program like a core product or service and weave it into your marketing strategy.

Don’t Ignore Milestones

A loyalty program isn’t just about transactions, points, and dollar values—it’s about celebrating your customers. Birthdays, holidays, and anniversaries offer meaningful opportunities to recognize and reward your patrons.

Consider offering exclusive deals on major holidays, bonus points on anniversaries, or free items on birthdays. These personal touches go a long way toward deepening customer relationships and fostering long-term loyalty.

Don’t Overcomplicate It

Consumers love simplicity. We expect seamless e-commerce checkouts, intuitive website navigation, and straightforward products. Your customer loyalty program should be no different.

If you burden your program with confusing rules, unclear rewards, or complicated redemption processes, your customers will likely become frustrated and disengaged. Keep it simple. The easier your program is to understand and use, the more successful it will be.

Remember—your loyalty program targets your very best customers. The simpler and more rewarding the experience, the stronger the engagement.

Revamp Your Customer Loyalty Program with JSL

Looking to strengthen relationships with existing customers and attract new ones? Look no further than JSL Marketing & Web Design!

We’re an award-winning, full-service digital marketing agency, and we’re ready to help you take your customer marketing to the next level. Your business has unique needs and goals—partner with a team that treats you like the one-of-a-kind brand you are. We never offer one-size-fits-all solutions. Everything we create is customized to your goals and business situation.

Depending on your marketing objectives, our experts may recommend a mix of services, including:

• Pay-Per-Click Advertising
• Social Media

• Email Marketing
• SEO
• Web Development
• Photography & Videography
• & More

Call now for a free consultation and start building a winning promotion strategy!